War & Conflicts Discussions => Wars & Conflicts: Books, Movies, Docus and Stories => Topic started by: MontyB on 14 June 2011, 03:07:07



Title: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 14 June 2011, 03:07:07
I am looking at picking up books by Niklas Zetterling, anyone tell me whether they are worthwhile or not?
The books are:
- Normandy 1944: German Military Organization, Combat Power and Organizational Effectiveness
- Kursk 1943: A Statistical Analysis (Soviet (Russian) Study of War)
- KORSUN POCKET: The Encirclement and Breakout of a German Army in the East, 1944
- BISMARCK: The Final Days of Germany's Greatest Battleship
- TIRPITZ: The Life and Death of Germany's Last Super Battleship

I figure I should pick up the whole bunch in one shot if they are any good.


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 14 June 2011, 04:50:55
They get high review ratings on Amazon.

Good Hunting.

MR


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 14 June 2011, 11:31:51
They get high review ratings on Amazon.

Good Hunting.

MR

Well that is something, what I am looking for is whether they are well written by someone that has researched the subject as opposed to something thrown together by someone that has watched the history channel too often for their own good.


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 15 June 2011, 01:52:42
Read the reviews by R. A Forczyk. He's a military officer I believe, and from what I've seen, has been spot on with his reviews of books I have; that I can compare against.

Good Hunting.

MR


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 15 June 2011, 21:58:47
Well I ordered the lot, at the very worst they will become expensive paper weights.
:)


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 17 June 2011, 08:44:44
I have some of those. Luckily not many. I have more books that are now worth considerably more than I paid for them than I do books that now have the value of a paperweight.

Good Hunting.

MR


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 17 June 2011, 09:30:46
Well even if they do suck they can't be any more boring that Antony Beevors - Crete, there is a book I just can't finish.


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 25 June 2011, 05:19:31
Did you get them yet?

Good Hunting.

MR


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 25 June 2011, 08:32:28
They haven't arrived yet it usually takes 2-3 weeks as I have to order them from the US.


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 8 August 2011, 02:32:35
I just got his book on the Germans at Normandy. If the rest of them are of the same quality I'd say you got a really good deal. His book on The Germans at Normandy has really good information in it.

Good Hunting.

MR


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 8 August 2011, 03:38:10
Yeah I have skimmed them and will get around to reading thing once I have finished:
1) Panzer Operations: The Eastern Front Memoir of General Raus 1941-1945
2) The Panzer Legions: A guide to the German Army Tank Divisions of World War 2 and their Commanders.

I have been busy buying books lately.

:)


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 9 August 2011, 00:43:51
I have been buying books lately as well.

In the past 3 months I've gotten:

Panzer Aces III by Franz Kurowski
Panzer Grenadier Aces by Franz Kurowski
The Face of Courage by Florian Berger
Hitler's Scientists by John Cornwell
The Americans at Normandy by John C. McManus
If You Survive by  George Wilson
Viking Panzers by Ewald Klapdor
Demolishing the Myth by Valeriy Zamulin
And No Birds Sang by Farley Mowat
Iron Knights by Gordon Blaker
The Germans in Normandy by Richard Hargreaves
Normandy 1944: German Military Organization, Combat Power and Organizational Effectiveness by Niklas Zetterling
Knight's Cross Panzers by Hans Schaufler
Zitadelle: The German Offensive Against the Kursk Salient 4-17 July 1943 by Mark Healy
Combat History of German Tiger Tank Battalion 503 in World War II by Franz-Wilhelm Lochmann, Alfred Rubbel and Richard Freiherr von Rosen
Battleground Prussian by Prit Buttar

So, I can understand being a bit behind on your reading.

Good Hunting.

MR


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: MontyB on 9 August 2011, 01:20:32
I have been meaning to read the Panzer Aces series, I have them but never got around to reading them.

I have also been looking at re-purchasing some of these books in Kindle format to see how they stack up, my book collection is starting to consume a lot of room so electronic format may be an option especially since I travel a lot.


Title: Re: Opinions wanted...
Post by: Mad_Russian on 9 August 2011, 02:09:45
I have hundreds and hundreds of books. Luckily I don't travel all that much any more.

Good Hunting.

MR